I have a reputation for rejecting rubber-banding. I’m much more likely to permit a check related to a roll because you flavored the roll in line with a trait than I am to grant an auto.

“Every time I do a thing boldly I succeed because I’m bold” wouldn’t cut it. For me auto success requires “show me how being bold uniquely positions you to be way better at this than someone prudent could be”.

In practice I suspect that would lead to the more specific traits being easier to ping for autos and harder to ping for marks while the broader ones are easier to ping for marks (they apply more often) but harder to ping for autos (because they are only rarely ‘just the perfect thing you need right now’)

But I freely admit that mostly my own standard and completely anecdotal.